PHYSICXION

Created by PHYSICXION © 2024

Beyond Regular Matter. Click here

⚠️ Stay Safe Online

This website will never ask for money except for paid services enlisted here or collect personal information in other ways online or offline. Stay vigilant and protect yourself from cyber fraud.
Home
Blog

Skipping the No Work Forces: What is the magic of Virtual work?

PHYSICXION:Imagine you're pushing a heavy table across the floor. You apply force, but strangely, Some of your effort is wasted due to friction.


Skipping the No Work Forces: What is the magic of Virtual work?


Imagine you're pushing a heavy table across the floor. You apply force, but strangely, not all of it helps move the table. Some of your effort is wasted due to friction, and if someone else is holding the table in place, no matter how hard you push, it won’t budge. The work you’re doing in that case? Completely useless—zero movement means zero work done in physics.

Now, imagine a different scenario. Instead of focusing on every force acting on the table—including friction, normal forces, and resistance—you only care about what actually contributes to its motion. What if you could ignore all unnecessary forces and focus only on the forces that do useful work?

That’s exactly what the principle of virtual work does in physics. It acts as a shortcut, filtering out unnecessary details so we can focus only on what truly drives motion. This idea became the backbone of Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics, allowing us to describe everything from simple pendulums to the motion of planets—without ever needing to track every individual force.

So, how did physicists take this idea and use it to revolutionize mechanics? Let’s break it down.

D'Alembert's Principle

D'Alembert’s Principle is a reformulation of Newton’s laws that incorporates the idea of virtual work, allowing us to analyze constrained mechanical systems more effectively. It states that the sum of the differences between the applied forces and the inertial forces (pseudo forces) for all particles, projected onto their virtual displacements, must be zero.

Mathematical Formulation

For a system of
N particles, the total force
Fi acting on the
i th particle consists of:
  • Fia\mathbf{F}_{ia}: Applied force
  • Fi\mathbf{F}_{i}: Constraint force
Using Newton's Second Law, the equation of motion for each particle is:

Fia+Fi=miai​

Rewriting acceleration in terms of velocity:
miai=miv˙i

Now, we define the inertial force (negative of mass times acceleration):

Pi=−miv˙i

D’Alembert’s principle states that the virtual work done by the net force (applied force minus inertial force) along any virtual displacement
δri must be zero:
∑i(Fia+Fi−miv˙i)⋅δri=0
Since the constraint forces
Fi do not contribute to virtual work (in ideal holonomic constraints), so we get: 

δW= virtual work i.e.

∑i(Fia−miv˙i)⋅δri=0\sum_{i} \left( \mathbf{F}_{ia} - m_i \dot{\mathbf{v}}_i \right) \cdot \delta \mathbf{r}_i = 0
Using the definition
Pi=miv˙i, we rewrite it as:
∑i(Fia−P˙i)⋅δri=0

Physical Interpretation

  • This principle removes the constraint forces from the equations, making it easier to analyze mechanical systems.
  • It leads naturally to Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics, which reformulate dynamics using energy principles rather than direct force equations

Now let's dive deeper to really understand how D'Alembert's principle is a reformulation of Newton's 2nd law and exactly how it is used to balance valid forces ignoring those that do no work.

D'Alembert’s Principle: Newton’s Second Law with a Twist

Imagine you are pushing a heavy shopping cart in a supermarket. At first, it takes some effort to get it moving, but once it’s rolling, you don’t have to push as hard to keep it going. If you suddenly stop pushing, the cart doesn’t stop immediately—it keeps rolling forward due to inertia.

Now, let’s say you’re moving it straight, but there’s a rubber mat on the floor that makes the cart slow down. Here, the friction from the mat acts like a constraint, subtly resisting motion without completely stopping it.
This everyday experience relates directly to Newton’s Second Law:

F=ma

Newton tells us that any force applied to an object changes its motion by producing acceleration. But what if we looked at the situation differently? Instead of focusing on forces causing acceleration, what if we described the motion as a balance between real forces and an additional "fictitious" force that represents resistance to motion?

This is exactly what D'Alembert’s Principle does! Instead of writing
F=ma, it rewrites the equation in a way that treats inertia as a kind of force itself:

F−ma=0

This may look simple, but it’s revolutionary! It tells us that instead of thinking of motion as something forced upon an object, we can think of it as a dynamic equilibrium between real forces and the object’s own resistance to acceleration (its inertia).

The Simplest Example: A Box on a Table

Let’s say you push a box on a table with a force
F. Newton’s law tells us:
F=ma

But D'Alembert reimagines it differently. He introduces a fictitious force called the inertial force, which is just -ma. Now, we write:
F−ma=0
This equation says that the applied force
F and the inertial force
−ma are in balance—like two people pulling a rope in a tug-of-war with equal force. The system behaves as if it is in equilibrium, even though it's actually moving.

Why is This Useful?

  1. Eliminating Constraint Forces: When we analyze complex systems (like pendulums, rolling balls, or robotic arms), some forces, like tensions or normal forces, don’t directly affect the movement. D’Alembert’s principle automatically removes those unnecessary forces from the equation.
  2. Bridging to Lagrangian Mechanics: This idea of treating motion as an equilibrium problem leads directly to more advanced physics techniques like Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics, which make solving problems much easier.

Newton’s Laws Reimagined

Newton saw forces as the reason for motion. D'Alembert, however, asked: What if we thought of forces as being naturally in balance? By shifting perspective, he transformed Newton’s Second Law into a powerful tool that makes solving complex motion problems much easier.

So, the next time you push a shopping cart, remember—you’re not just applying force, you’re engaging in a battle between real forces and the silent force of inertia. And D'Alembert made that battle much easier to understand! 

What is the exact stand of no workforces in this theory?

In D'Alembert's principle, there is no explicit concept of a "no-work force" in the way we think about it in Newtonian mechanics (like normal forces in static cases). Instead, the principle naturally eliminates forces that do no virtual work by focusing on virtual displacements.

How?

D'Alembert's principle states that for a system in dynamic equilibrium, the sum of the applied forces and the inertial forces must result in zero virtual work for any possible (virtual) displacement:

∑(Fi−miai)⋅δri=0


This means we only consider displacements that could happen in an idealized, constraint-free way. If a force does no work for any possible virtual displacement (e.g., normal force in purely horizontal motion), it automatically disappears from the equation without needing to be explicitly ignored.

So, does D'Alembert's principle consider "no-work forces"?

  • Yes, in a way—they exist in the system but don’t contribute to virtual work.
  • No, practically—because the principle inherently ignores them through virtual displacements, so we never explicitly deal with them.
This is why Lagrangian mechanics, which is built on D'Alembert's principle and the principle of virtual work, lets us completely avoid dealing with constraint forces like tension or normal forces unless they directly influence motion.

Physical Significance of Virtual Work in D'Alembert's Principle

D'Alembert’s principle is a powerful reformulation of Newton’s laws of motion that makes solving problems in mechanics more intuitive, especially in constrained systems. The concept of virtual work plays a crucial role in this principle.

Why Introduce Virtual Work?

The introduction of virtual work in D’Alembert’s principle serves several purposes:

  • Eliminating Constraint Forces: Many mechanical systems involve constraints (e.g., a bead on a wire, a pendulum, or a car on a road). Directly solving for constraint forces can be difficult. D’Alembert’s principle uses virtual work to avoid explicitly calculating these forces by ensuring that constraint forces do no virtual work.
  • Bridging Newtonian and Lagrangian Mechanics: Newton’s laws deal with forces, while Lagrangian mechanics focuses on energy. Virtual work provides a natural transition between these two frameworks, leading to powerful analytical mechanics methods.
  • Simplifying Equations of Motion: Instead of dealing with vector equations for every force, the virtual work formulation allows us to derive equations using scalars (work and energy), making complex systems easier to analyze.

Physical Meaning of Virtual Work in D'Alembert’s Principle

  • Virtual Work vs. Actual Work:
    • Actual Work is done when a real displacement occurs over time.
    • Virtual Work is an infinitesimal hypothetical displacement of a system that respects its constraints at a given instant. It helps analyze forces without considering real motion.
  • Role in Dynamics: D’Alembert’s principle states that the sum of the real forces and the inertial forces produces zero virtual work. This reinterprets Newton’s second law as a balance of forces in the virtual displacement framework.
Mathematically, it is expressed as:
∑(Fi−miai)⋅δri=0
where
δri is a virtual displacement. This means that instead of treating forces directly, we consider how forces would theoretically move the system within its constraints.

The Importance of Virtual Work in Developing Lagrangian and Hamiltonian Mechanics

Virtual work plays a fundamental role in transitioning from Newtonian mechanics to Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics. It provides an elegant way to describe motion without directly dealing with forces, making it particularly useful for complex and constrained systems.

1. Virtual Work as a Bridge to Analytical Mechanics

  • Newtonian mechanics describes motion using forces and accelerations. However, in many cases, explicitly handling forces (especially constraint forces) is impractical.
  • Virtual work helps eliminate constraint forces, allowing a system to be described in terms of generalized coordinates rather than forces.
  • This leads naturally to Lagrange’s equations, which describe motion purely in terms of energy functions.

2. Connection to D’Alembert’s Principle

  • D'Alembert’s principle extends Newton’s laws by introducing inertial forces, leading to the equation: ∑(Fi−miai)⋅δri=0
  • Since constraint forces do no virtual work, this allows us to focus only on the active forces and the system's generalized coordinates.
  • This principle directly leads to the principle of least action, which is the foundation of Lagrangian mechanics.

3. Role in Lagrangian Mechanics

  • In Lagrangian mechanics, motion is determined by the principle of least action, which minimizes the integral of the Lagrangian: L=T−VL = T - V where TT is kinetic energy and VV is potential energy.
  • The virtual work principle helps eliminate constraint forces, leading to the Euler-Lagrange equations: ddt(∂L∂q˙i)−∂L∂qi=0\frac{d}{dt} \left( \frac{\partial L}{\partial \dot{q}_i} \right) - \frac{\partial L}{\partial q_i} = 0where qiq_i are generalized coordinates.
By formulating dynamics in terms of energy rather than forces, Lagrangian mechanics provides a more flexible and powerful approach for complex systems like electromagnetism, fluid mechanics, and quantum field theory.

4. Role in Hamiltonian Mechanics

  • Hamiltonian mechanics refines Lagrangian mechanics by reformulating motion in terms of generalized coordinates qiq_i and generalized momenta pip_i: H=∑piq˙i−LH = \sum p_i \dot{q}_i - L
  • The equations of motion become: q˙i=∂H∂pi,p˙i=−∂H∂qi
  • This formulation is crucial in statistical mechanics, quantum mechanics, and relativity, where phase-space methods are essential.

Conclusion: 

The virtual work concept in D'Alembert's principle provides a constraint-friendly, force-independent approach to mechanics. It transforms Newtonian mechanics into a form that is easier to handle mathematically, leading to Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics, which are widely used in theoretical physics and engineering.

Why Virtual Work is Crucial

  1. Eliminates constraint forces, allowing a more general description of motion.
  2. Provides a foundation for energy-based formulations, leading to the principle of least action.
  3. Simplifies complex systems (e.g., multi-body, electromagnetic, relativistic) by using generalized coordinates.
  4. This leads to Hamiltonian mechanics, which is essential in quantum mechanics and statistical physics.
Thus, the concept of virtual work is the key stepping stone from classical force-based physics to the powerful, abstract formulations of Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics, which dominate modern theoretical physics.

Explore more categories from PHYSICXION:

[Blog] [Question and Numerical] [Course Catalouge High School] [Course Catalogue B.Sc] [Course Catalogue M.Sc] [Entrance Hub] [Paid Materials]